Bwana Karani

DEAR VIEWERS - REGRET TEMPORARY TECHNICAL FAULT ACCESSING ALL PHOTOGRAPHS IN THIS POSTING.
PROBLEM WILL SOON BE RECTIFIED.






Hi Benny,


Memoirs of a Goan civil servant in the  provincial administration in outlying areas, such as the D.C.'s office, Northern Frontier District. Fascinating and nostalgic portrait of Kenya in colonial days.
The things they said about BWANA KARANI………. 
Many were the Reviews and personal letters received following the publication of
Mervyn Maciel’s East African memoirs in 1985. From these, and following requests from family and friends, the author has selected a random ‘snapshot’ which he describes as “Words money cannot buy” and now shares these  with you…..
From Personal Letters:
1. From Sir Richard Turnbull, Acting Governor of Kenya, latterly first Governor-General of independent Tanganyika, then High Commissioner, Aden, who contributed the Foreword to the book:
“Congratulations on the finished product.  I had the pleasure of seeing in fair print, the pages over which you have been working with such patience and determination. It is a volume which you can be justifiably proud of. I too am proud to have been associated with the work and cemented such a valuable friendship.”
2. From Mr Benjamin Kipkulel, Kenya High Commissioner in London:
 “I am so glad my two Cultural Attaches represented me well at the book launch which sadly I could not attend. I have had the opportunity of browsing through your book and find it most fascinating.
3. From Mr. Christopher Denton, Private Secretary to the Governor of Kenya:
“I enjoyed your book immensely. It certainly fills an important gap in the bibliography of Kenya, and I hope it will be regarded as the major achievement it deserves to be”.
 4. From Sir Geoffrey Ellerton, Clerk to the Kenya Legislative Council
“Your book, I am sure, has given a wider pleasure than even you imagined, and I hope that will give you a deep satisfaction. I enjoyed it so much and am now ordering copies for my grandchildren.”
 5. From Mr. Colin Campbell, former District Commissioner, Kenya and latterly Administrator of the Falkland Islands:
“I am enjoying your book enormously. One thing in it struck me forcibly – how fortunate the Goans in Kenya were to have such a close knit, hospitable and supportive community.”
 6. From Mr. Noel Hardy, former D.C. Kenya:
“Once again, many thanks for all the pleasure your book has given me; a powerful reminder, if one was needed, of the dedication and loyalty we received from you and your Goan colleagues – the backbone of the Provincial Administration.”
 7. From Mr. ‘Bob’ Otter, former D.C. Kenya:
“Congratulations on your book. It certainly was a most enjoyable trip down memory lane.”
 8. From Mr. George Grimmett, former D.C. Kenya:
“Thank you so much for all the pleasure your book has given. I enjoyed it immensely as it brought back so many memories on almost every page.”
9. From Mr. Denis Lakin, former D.C. Kenya:
“I was a member of the Provincial Administration during your time, but unfortunately we never met. My many happy memories include many of that devoted band of “Bwana Karanis” who served the then Government so faithfully and so well. My delay in writing doesn’t conceal my admiration for your book, and the effort that went into its making.”
 10. From Sir John Cumber, former D.C., Kenya, latterly, Director ‘Save the Children Fund’:
“I might have missed a gem had I not heard of your book. Printed nostalgia at that price sounds a real bargain tome.”
11. From Mr. Hugh Walker, former D.C. Kenya:
“I was first introduced to your book by Chris Minter, whom I think you know. I am so glad you wrote the book for posterity, as without the Goan community (the salt of the earth), the Provincial Administration would never have achieved the standards it did.”
 12. From Mr. Roland Hill, last D.C. of Lusaka, Zambia:
“As an Africanist myself, I wanted to tell you how significant your book has been in the history of British Colonial Africa and a wonderful record for posterity.”
13. From Mrs. Kay Wild, wife of former D.C. “Windy” Wild:
“Bwana Karani has arrived and how I loved the book. The way you have written is, to my mind, excellent, as a complete stranger to the N.F.D. (Northern Frontier District), and life in Kenya, can’t help but get the feel of the country.”
 14. From Professor Paul Baxter, Dept. of Social Anthropology, University of Manchester, and formerly Anthropologist in Northern Kenya:
“I ordered a copy of Bwana Karani for our library, and have just finished reading it. My enjoyment nudged me out of my sloth to respond and tell you how much I liked it.”
 15. From Mrs. Margaret Sutherland (nee Finch) former D.C.’s Secretary, Kenya:
“I wish I had ordered Bwana Karani” through you. Elspeth Huxley and I keep up a vague sort of correspondence, and she mentioned your book and said how good it was.”
 16. From Dr. Pascal Imperato Distinguished Service Professor, Brooklyn, New York, and himself the author of several books on Africana:
“Your story is a truly fascinating one that will be of great historical interest to future generations. I think you are far too modest though.”
 17. From Mrs. Elspeth Huxley, best known chronicler of Colonial Kenya and author of over 40 books:
“What an exciting surprise. It’s a beautiful book and I look forward enormously to reading it properly after a preliminary skim through. I know I shall enjoy every page, seeing I know so many of the people and places you describe.”(An extract from Huxley’s excellent Review appears later in these pages.
 18. From Dr. Bill Barton, former Medical Officer of Health, Kenya, later Director of Medical Services, Zanzibar:
“Your book truly opened my eyes to the inner workings of the D.C.’s offices. I had always known of the great respect in which you, Goans, were held by the Administration, but was ignorant of the racial discrimination that operated in such issues as travel, housing and hospital privileges.”
 19. From Mr. Joe da Cunha, a former colleague in the Administration:
“Have so far only read half the book well done, I like it. You have recorded us in history.”
 20.From Mrs. Jane D’Souza, daughter of former Administration colleague:
“Your book gave me tremendous pleasure. Reading through, I built up images of the one time realties of my life in Kenya. Thanks again for the many hours of reading pleasure. It is a book I will definitely read again.”
 21. From Mr. Ben Antao, Journalist, Teacher & Author, Canada:
“I found your book an interesting read. Thanks to you, I am now made aware that life in East Africa was not all milk and honey.”
 Extracts from Press & Other Reviews:

1.From Dr. David Killingray of Goldsmith College, University of London, writing in the journal of the Royal African Society:
 “This memoir of life in Kenya in the fifties is based on what must be carefully kept diaries. It records daily boma life as  appeared through the eyes of a sensitive, enterprising and active Goan, who was eager to expose himself to all that life could offer, rough or smooth. The author’s open nature is apparent in the style and narrative itself. The book hardly contains a harsh word, though a few people he mentions probably deserved them.”
2.From veteran British author of “The Flame Trees of Thika” fame, Elspeth Huxley:
“Informally and pleasingly written, Mervyn Maciel’s book chronicles a slice of Kenya’s history from an unfamiliar angle, and puts on record the part played by the Goan community whose integrity and industry underpinned so much of the development of their adopted land. He loved his job, got on famously with almost everyone, from Boran cattle herds to British Provincial Commissioners, had a happy marriage and was a happy man- a nice change in this so often troubled and acrimonious world.”
 3.From well-known Kenya author, Cynthia Salvadori, writing in the journal of the
Kenya Institute of Management:
“We each see the world through our eyes, but one of the greatest values of published memoirs is that it enables us to get glimpses through other people’s eyes. Mervyn Maciel’s Bwana Karani is a real eye-opener. It is the only personal account that has ever been published by any member of the Asian community in Kenya. We have innumerable records of life in the early days by Europeans in Kenya. The immense success of the film version of Isak Dinesan’s partial autobiography, ‘Out of Africa’  had provoked a resurgence  of criticism  that accounts of life in colonial Kenya are all one-sided, from the European’s view point. That the view is unbalanced is the fault of the non-Europeans, and I am deeply and personally grateful to Mervyn Maciel, for his is the only work of its kind to be published by a member of any Asian community in Kenya. His style is totally unpretentious, and appreciation of the wilderness sincere. His Goan colleagues should be delighted that their existence has been so well recorded for posterity, and what shines through the ordinary prose and mundane preoccupations is Maciel’s profound liking and appreciation of other people. Through his book, we, non-Goans are made aware of the amazing Goan network that spread all over Kenya, a network through which flowed the very life blood of the colonial administration.”
 4.From the Sunday Nation, Nairobi:
“Mervyn Maciel’s ‘Bwana Karani’ is a winner. Not only will students of history find it a useful manuscript, but those working in the so-called hardship areas will get some consolation in reading this first hand account of a dedicated worker who served in those areas with an ailing child.”
 5. From the Nairobi Weekly Review:
“Bwana Karani is an excellent personal memoir of Mervyn Maciel’s life and times in Kenya. His style is captivating, exciting in some situations and full of detail. Even diaries could not be as detailed in specifics as his book is. It is a Roots of sorts, and what a journey it is! His love and warmth of the people –African people cannot be mistaken.”
 6.From the Sutton & District Guardian:
“Mr. Maciel should be congratulated on his fluent and digestible style. His book reads almost like a newsletter home”
 7.From the Sutton Herald:
“Full of nostalgic memories of Kenya during the colonial era, his book carries a Foreword by Sir Richard Turnbull, first Governor-General of Tanganyika.”
 8. From the North Devon Journal:
“Snakes invading the office, a narrow escape from an angry buffalo, a murder plot, are all in a day’s work for a government official in darkest Kenya. It is a tale of life very different from that in Britain in the 40s, 50s and 60s, and chronicles in great detail a career in a now-past colonial era and paints an absorbing picture of life in the remoter parts of Kenya where wild animals roamed.”
8.From The Examiner, Bombay.
 “This is one man’s story of life in the African bush. He writes in a quiet, somewhat slow relaxed and homely style, recalling with great detail the many aspects and events of his stay in Africa.”
9. From Goa Today (Lambert Mascarenhas):
“This is another self expression by a Goan settled abroad, a memorabilia laced with nostalgia and saudade of the life and times lived by the author in Kenya, not Nairobi or Mombasa which offered many amenities and divertimento, and where, after a day’s work, the Goan, his wife and children converged on the Institutes or Clubs to spend a pleasant evening, but the Kenya of the wild Northern Frontier districts”
 10. From Alvaro Collaco, former Senior Civil Servant, Uganda Government “Your book proved such compulsive reading, that I have only just put it down after reading it from cover to cover. Congratulations.”
11. From Roland D’Souza, former member Provincial Administration, Kenya:
“I admire your courage and the time and effort you have put into this book. I am really proud of you.”
 12. From Francisco da Costa in San Francisco: “You have done us (Goans) proud, and made an excellent job of the book”
Note: Bwana Karani now features in the International Africa bibliography edited by Dr. Hector Blackhurst. The Colonial Office archives and the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford have also acquired copies. A copy has also been donated to the Kenya National Archives and the British Empire & Commonwealth Museum in Bristol.
Although the book is now out of print, copies are still available through some of the Specialist bookshops in the U.K. and also through AMAZON via the internet.

  
Mervyn & Elsie at their Shamba in Sutton. Mervyn with some of the Shamba
  Produce.
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment